A Guide to the Upcoming Presidential Debate
Elections & Politics | By: Inijah Quadri| August 30, 2024
Featured Photo: Official MSNBC YouTube (WATCH LIVE: Harris and Trump Presidential Debate)
__________________________________
Presidential debates remain a vital part of the democratic process, providing voters with a direct view of how candidates present their policies and react under pressure. The 2024 general election features an upcoming debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris on September 10, 2024, which has garnered heightened attention due to the stark differences in their debate styles. Trump’s tendency toward aggressive, unscripted exchanges and Harris’s measured, policy-driven approach are expected to set the tone for this critical debate. The debate between Tim Walz and JD Vance, set for October 1, will also play a crucial role in the vice-presidential race.
Analysis
The presidential debates in 2024 face challenges in ensuring fairness, especially given Trump’s historical tendency to break from traditional debate norms. Trump is known for turning debates into a spectacle, often dominating conversations through verbal aggression and personal attacks. In the chaotic 2020 debates, such tactics led to widespread frustration with the lack of substantive discussion. As a result, microphone muting systems were introduced for 2024, designed to prevent interruptions. However, Kamala Harris has notably rejected the use of these mute functions for the upcoming debate, signaling her confidence in addressing Trump’s direct attacks without enforced silencing.
Harris’s strategy appears to focus on confronting Trump’s rhetoric head-on, allowing for immediate rebuttals rather than relying on a mute button. This reflects her debate style—calm, composed, and fact-oriented. Her strength lies in presenting clear, structured arguments, which could help her dismantle Trump’s less policy-focused approach. However, Harris’s challenge will be maintaining composure amidst Trump’s unpredictability. Trump’s strength is his ability to engage his base with a high-energy performance, but his weakness lies in his frequent disregard for facts, which Harris is likely to highlight.
Moderators are the gatekeepers of debate integrity, responsible for maintaining order and ensuring that candidates adhere to the rules. In 2024, moderators like Jake Tapper and Dana Bash have been selected for their experience and ability to navigate contentious discussions. The effectiveness of these moderators will be judged by their ability to pose challenging, relevant questions while ensuring that each candidate has a fair opportunity to respond.
This year’s debate formats also reflect a broader shift in how debates are consumed. The decision to eliminate live audiences, focusing attention solely on the candidates’ responses and removing the distractions of applause or audience reactions is rather welcome. This makes it even more important for candidates to deliver concise, impactful statements that resonate with online audiences.
In addition to the presidential debate on September 10, the vice-presidential race between Tim Walz and JD Vance is heating up, with their first debate scheduled for October 1, 2024, hosted by CBS News. This debate is expected to focus heavily on national security, the economy, and the candidates’ records in office.
Walz, known for his calm demeanor and emphasis on policy, will need to highlight his experience governing Minnesota, while Vance, a political newcomer, will likely leverage his populist appeal to Trump’s base. Both candidates face the challenge of engaging undecided voters without alienating their core supporters.
Indicators of a Successful Debate
For voters, a successful debate is one that fosters clarity, civility, and substantive policy discussion. The September 10 debate will be judged by its ability to inform the electorate about the candidates’ positions and leadership styles. Key indicators of success include adherence to debate rules, a balance between policy and personality, and a fair and controlled exchange of ideas.
The debates are an opportunity for candidates to communicate directly with the public, especially undecided voters. As Trump, Harris, Walz, and Vance prepare for their respective debates, they will need to balance appeals to their base with messages that resonate more broadly. Ultimately, the impact of these debates on the election will depend on how well the candidates communicate their vision for the country’s future.
Engagement Resources:
- Commission on Presidential Debates: The official body responsible for organizing and overseeing presidential debates in the United States.
- The Brookings Institution: Research and insights on the history and impact of presidential debates.
- Presidential Campaigns, Debates, and Endorsements Archive: A resource offering historical documents and information on past presidential campaigns and debates.
Stay in-the-know! Always get the latest updates from our reporters by subscribing to the U.S. Resist News Weekly Newsletter. Your support is crucial in safeguarding fearless independent journalism. If you appreciate our content, please consider donating today to help protect democracy and empower citizenship.