Summary
Billionaires spent millions to defeat a ballot measure that would have imposed a one-time tax on the wealthiest Californians to fund healthcare programs and services cut by the Trump Big Bad Budget Bill. Accustomed to not paying their fair share, they poured their money into misleading and deceptive ads and, with help from establishment democrats like Governor Gavin Newsom, defeated Proposition 40.
Analysis
It is generally true that the wealthier you the easier it is to avoid tax taxes. Case in point: Sergey Brin and Larry Page, co-founders of Google and two of the wealthiest people on earth. According to Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman, the award-winning economists behind Proposition 40, neither Brin nor Page paid any California income taxes in 2019, 2020, and 2023, a period of time during which the combined value of their Google interests grew by around $60 billion.
Brin and Page didn’t have to do anything special to avoid paying for their gains; the California tax code makes it easy. During those years, neither of them took a salary from Google, nor did they sell any Google shares or receive any dividend payments.
That’s why Zucman and Saez, who previously worked with Senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren on wealth-tax plans, wrote Proposition 40 as a one-time tax on assets. The tax would only have applied to approximately 225 California residents with more than $1 billion in assets.
The measure would have raised an estimated $1 billion. An average, run-of-the-mill billionaire would have paid around $150 million; the obscenely wealthier ones would have paid more. Larry Page, with a net worth of $268 billion, would have paid $13.4 billion; Brin’s slightly smaller fortune would have resulted in a tax bill of $12.4 billion.
Saez and Zucman wrote the law to apply to any billionaire who lived in the state on January 1, 2026. Still, after the measure qualified for the ballot, both Brin and Page moved out of state.
Poor Mark Zuckerberg, only the 5th wealthiest person in the world, would have been forced to pony up around $ 11 billion, leaving him with a vastly diminished net worth of approximately $205 billion, a prospect he apparently found alarming. Luckily, after he told Meta’s board he would have to leave California, where the company is headquartered, to avoid the tax, the board agreed to pay it for him.
Brin covered all his bases; despite moving to Nevada, he was the top funder of Building a Better California, the main PAC that fought Prop 40, whose $425 million campaign turned around the measure’s initial polling support. In addition to defeating Prop 40, the PAC pushed a countermeasure that would have effectively nullified Prop 40 if it had passed and included language to prevent future wealth taxes.
Although the state Democratic Party endorsed Proposition 40, Governor Newsom opposed it and appeared in relentless ads, texts, and mailers parroting the billionaires’ claims that they would leave the state if Prop 40 passed, utterly depleting California’s tax base. Ads for Proposition 42, 40’s poison pill, falsely claimed it was necessary to protect all Californians’ retirement savings, suggesting that Prop 40’s taxes would apply to everyone’s assets, not just billionaires. A text I received while writing this read: “Vote yes on 42 by 8 pm tomorrow to protect your retirement and savings from new taxes. Other ads alluded to ‘spending with no oversight.”
With California set to lose around $100 billion in federal Medicaid funds, cutbacks are expected in health care coverage for millions of low-income residents and will likely mean closures of hospitals and other healthcare facilities. The Service Employees International Union, California’s large and influential healthcare workers union, put Prop 40 on the ballot to offset those cuts. After it was defeated, numerous media outlets proclaimed “voters rejected the billionaire tax”, which doesn’t seem accurate. Billionaires defeated the tax the way they’ve defeated other popular ballot measures, by spending outrageous, unheard-of amounts of money on deceptive and dishonest ads.
Take Action
- How to Tax the Ultrarich by Brian Galle, Jan. 9, 2026
https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/how-to-tax-the-ultrarich/ - The Many Ways to Tax the Rich by Howard Gleckman, March 31, 2022
https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/many-ways-tax-rich

