Summary

Since President Trump’s second term began in January 2025, at least nine people have been fatally shot by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Border Patrol agents, according to a recent CBS News analysis. In several cases, federal authorities have blocked independent investigations, withheld evidence, and restricted state and local investigators’ access to information. The lack of independent scrutiny shields the administration from accountability and leaves victims’ families without answers.

The federal government has repeatedly framed the victims as threats and classified evidence as part of federal law enforcement actions, limiting state and local authorities’ access to it. Four cases show the Trump administration’s playbook of obstructing independent investigations, and how state and local officials and victims’ families are fighting back.

Analysis

In January, ICE agent Jonathan Ross shot and killed 37-year-old American woman Renée Good in her car. Three weeks later, Border Patrol agent Jesus Ochoa and Customs and Border Protection officer Raymundo Gutierrez shot and killed 37-year-old American Alex Pretti as he lay pinned face down on the ground. Despite numerous eyewitness accounts, the federal government denied state investigators access to the shooting scenes. In Pretti’s case, Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) state investigators were physically blocked from entering the scene despite having a search warrant from a Hennepin County judge.

After reaching an agreement to share evidence with Minnesota officials, the Justice Department abruptly stopped sharing evidence. According to court filings cited by CNN, federal investigators are withholding key evidence, including the cellphone of the agent who killed Good, her clothing, firearms used to shoot Pretti, the gun Pretti possessed, and other physical evidence, such as projectiles and shell casings. Investigators also say they have not received a recording of a statement by one of the officers who shot Pretti. Meanwhile, the federal government—which was quick to blame the victims in both cases despite video evidence contradicting its claims—has shown no signs of conducting an investigation

In July, Lorenzo Salgado Araujo, a 52-year-old Mexican national, was fatally shot by an ICE agent in Houston, Texas. Araujo, a home-builder and father of three boys, had lived in the U.S. for 35 years. His family said he was gathering documents for a work permit application and was nearing legal status. Less than a week later, Joan Sebastian Durán Guerrero, a 25-year-old Colombian man, was shot and killed by ICE agents in Biddeford, Maine. Guerrero was a lawful asylum seeker with a work permit and a Social Security number, and no criminal history. He and his partner had a 3-year-old daughter.

Their deaths sparked nationwide anti-ICE protests and calls from lawmakers and human rights organizations for independent investigations. The Trump administration continues to blame the victims, refuse to share evidence, withhold the names of the agents involved, and block  independent civilian or state homicide investigations.

Fighting for justice

Good’s family has filed two lawsuits against the U.S. government, alleging wrongful death and conspiracy to conceal evidence. Minnesota state officials have sued the Trump administration. Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty said that the federal government had adopted a “policy of categorically withholding evidence” from the ICE killings of Good and Pretti, as well as a third ICE shooting that injured Minneapolis resident Julio Sosa-Celis.

Pretti’s parents have accused the DOJ of violating their rights under a federal victims’ rights law, as reported by CNN, and of “shielding Alex’s killers” by withholding the federal case file from state investigators. Their attorney wrote to Attorney General Todd Blanche, asking the DOJ to identify the federal employees who shot their son, honor its evidence-sharing agreement, and confirm whether the FBI is still investigating Pretti’s killing.

After Salgado Araujo’s death, Texas lawmakers demanded a review of all evidence from the scene. The Harris County district attorney has been collecting evidence in the case to determine what charges to present to a grand jury. While the federal government has refused to release the name of the officer who allegedly shot Salgado Araujo, despite its own advice to local police departments, The Texas Tribune identified the ICE officer as Gregory Feathers, citing an official familiar with the investigation.

Durán Guerrero’s family and their attorney have pressed the government for more information on the purported federal investigation. Lawmakers Robert Garcia, ranking member of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, and Richard Blumenthal, ranking member of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, demanded answers from the Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers regarding the vetting and training of ICE officers. According to reports, ICE officer David Brouillette who killed Durán Guerrero has a history of domestic violence and mental health issues.

Conclusion

Under the Trump administration, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) continues to invoke federal immunity for its officers, dispute subpoenas, delay the release of footage, and block independent reviews. The federal government’s handling of these civilian deaths reflects a callous disregard for transparency and accountability. It also undermines the administration’s claims to uphold law and order.

The victim’s families deserve answers from the federal government. They deserve justice.

DONATE NOW
Subscribe Below to Our News Service

x
x
Support fearless journalism! Your contribution, big or small, dismantles corruption and sparks meaningful change. As an independent outlet, we rely on readers like you to champion the cause of transparent and accountable governance. Every donation fuels our mission for insightful policy reporting, a cornerstone for informed citizenship. Help safeguard democracy from tyrants—donate today. Your generosity fosters hope for a just and equitable society.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This