Ownership in Emerging Frontiers: Outer Space and Cyberspace

Foreign Policy Brief #177 | By: Inijah Quadri | February 10, 2025

Featured Photo From: techradar.com

__________________________________

The ownership of outer space and cyberspace has become a critical issue as humanity expands its activities into these domains. Outer space, once the realm of government-led exploration, is now increasingly commercialized with private companies launching satellites, planning lunar missions, and pursuing asteroid mining. Similarly, cyberspace, the digital environment that underpins global communication and commerce, is witnessing debates over data sovereignty, digital monopolies, and intellectual property.

Both outer space and cyberspace are often described as global commons—areas intended for shared use and benefit. However, the lack of clear, universally accepted regulations on ownership and usage has sparked controversies. In outer space, the question arises over who owns resources extracted from celestial bodies, while in cyberspace, concerns center on who controls digital infrastructure and data.

These issues are not just theoretical. They carry profound implications for global equity, security, and the sustainable use of resources. Without cohesive policies, there is a risk of exploitation, conflict, and inequitable distribution of the benefits from these emerging frontiers.

Analysis

Outer Space

The 1967 Outer Space Treaty, the cornerstone of international space law, establishes that outer space is not subject to national sovereignty. Article II of the treaty prohibits any nation from claiming ownership of celestial bodies. However, as private companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin lead the charge into space exploration, the treaty’s limitations are becoming evident.

For instance, the United States and Luxembourg have enacted laws allowing private companies to own resources mined from celestial bodies. While these laws aim to encourage investment and innovation, they challenge the treaty’s spirit by creating a legal gray area about the commercialization of space resources. The Moon Agreement of 1979 sought to address such concerns but failed to gain widespread adoption, leaving critical gaps in governance.

Cyberspace

Unlike outer space, cyberspace lacks a unified international treaty. Ownership in cyberspace is largely governed by a patchwork of national laws, international agreements, and corporate policies. Intellectual property rights protect digital content and software, while data sovereignty laws dictate how information can be stored and transferred across borders.

However, cyberspace governance faces significant challenges. Major tech companies dominate the digital landscape, controlling vast amounts of user data and the infrastructure of the internet. This concentration of power raises questions about monopolies, data privacy, and the equitable distribution of digital resources. The global nature of cyberspace complicates regulation, as legal frameworks vary widely between countries.

Policy Recommendations

To address the challenges of ownership in outer space and cyberspace, an international coalition could establish a new framework akin to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. 

For outer space, this could include:

• Guidelines for resource extraction to ensure equitable access.
• Mechanisms for resolving disputes between nations and private entities.
• Collaborative efforts to prevent the militarization of space.

For the cyberspace, this could include:

• International agreements on data privacy and cybersecurity.
• Regulations to address digital monopolies and ensure fair competition.
• Public-private partnerships to enhance the transparency and accountability of tech companies.

This framework would ensure that activities in these domains are conducted transparently, sustainably, and equitably, with shared benefits for all nations. By defining clear guidelines for resource extraction in space and data governance in the cyberspace, this initiative could prevent conflicts and promote cooperation in these rapidly evolving frontiers.

Stay in-the-know! Always get the latest updates from our reporters by subscribing to the U.S. Resist Democracy Weekly Newsletter, and please consider contributing to ‘Keeping Democracy Alive’ by donating today! We depend on support from readers like you to aide in protecting fearless independent journalism.