As we enter the second month of Donald Trump’s return to office, his stance on immigration remains as hardline as ever—if not more extreme. He has ramped up his rhetoric against so-called “criminals,” but communities across the country are feeling the tangible effects of his deportation policies. Friends, neighbors, workers, and community members are being forcibly removed, leaving behind fractured families and economic instability.

Beyond just rhetoric, Trump has resorted to extraordinary measures, including the deportation of detainees to former terrorist prison camps such as Guantánamo Bay. He claims that only the “worst of the worst” are being sent there—cartel members, rapists, and felons—but the reality is starkly different. The administration is struggling to find enough violent criminals to justify its heavy-handed approach because, contrary to Trump’s claims, millions of criminals are not flooding the border daily.

ICE operations have surged across the country, leading to the detention of more than just violent offenders. Due to pressure to meet quotas set by Trump, ICE agents have been rounding up non-violent individuals, including long-time residents with families and jobs in the U.S. Horror stories have begun to emerge, such as the tragic case of Jocelynn Rojo Carranza, an 11-year-old girl from Texas who took her own life after being bullied over her parents’ legal status and deportation. These stories underscore the human cost of Trump’s policies and highlight the broader impact of his administration’s targeting and persecution of immigrants.

Analysis

Since Trump took office, arrests of undocumented immigrants have surged dramatically. In late January alone, ICE arrested an average of 872 people per day—more than three times the 255 daily arrests under Joe Biden. However, deportations have not kept pace. The daily deportation rate stands at 600, which is lower than the 750 per day recorded last year under Biden.

According to Reuters, Trump deported 37,660 individuals in his first month—far below the monthly average of 57,000 seen during Biden’s final year. February’s arrest numbers also dropped sharply from 141,000 in February 2024, declining further from 29,000 in January. Meanwhile, over 3,000 detainees have been released back into the country, complicating the administration’s aggressive immigration strategy.

Under Biden, deportation efforts focused primarily on border crossers, with fewer interior arrests. Trump’s administration has shifted the focus, closing off much of the border and ramping up interior enforcement, leading to a sharp increase in ICE raids and detentions within U.S. communities. While more undocumented immigrants are being detained, deportations remain slow due to logistical bottlenecks and legal challenges.

With increased arrests, the detention system is nearing crisis levels. The number of detained immigrants has grown by more than 4,000 in just one month, pushing the total to nearly 44,000. Unlike under Biden—when many detainees were released under parole or bond—Trump’s ICE has significantly curtailed these releases. As a result, detention centers are overcrowded, and backlogs in processing cases continue to mount.

Although Trump initially pledged to prioritize violent criminals for deportation, the data tells a different story. The percentage of detainees with no criminal record has jumped from 6% to 16% since mid-January, suggesting that non-violent individuals are being disproportionately targeted. This raises serious concerns about the fairness and efficiency of the administration’s immigration enforcement policies.

Despite Trump’s vow to deport millions of undocumented immigrants, the numbers suggest this goal is unrealistic unless enforcement efforts escalate drastically. Republicans in Congress are calling for increased funding, and Trump is expanding military involvement in immigration enforcement, which could intensify removals in the coming months.

The individuals most affected by Trump’s policies include undocumented migrants, asylum seekers, and those previously protected under programs like Temporary Protected Status (TPS). The administration has targeted Haitians, Mexicans, and Panamanians, stripping away protections and rounding up individuals indiscriminately. Contrary to Trump’s initial claims, long-term residents are being arrested alongside recent arrivals, often without regard for their criminal history.

While arrests are soaring, deportations remain sluggish. Those who are deported can find themselves sent to countries like Panama, regardless of whether they are originally from there. Challenges with repatriation agreements and legal barriers have also led to cases where deportees are placed in dangerous conditions upon arrival.

Reports have surfaced of migrants being detained at Guantánamo Bay, sparking alarm over offshore processing and human rights concerns. The use of third-country detention centers—such as Panama—has led to international legal debates about the treatment of detainees and the ethics of outsourcing deportations.

While border crossings have declined, it remains unclear whether this is due to Trump’s immigration crackdown, Mexico’s National Guard deployments, or broader geopolitical shifts. Meanwhile, legal battles and grassroots resistance are growing, with communities mobilizing to protest the detainment and deportation of their neighbors, friends, and family members.

Politically, Trump’s approval ratings have taken a hit as his extreme immigration policies face mounting backlash. The economic and social repercussions of mass deportations are still unfolding, but they risk creating more instability than deterrence. The key question remains: is Trump’s crackdown a sustainable solution, or will it ultimately lead to greater challenges for the United States?

Engagement Resources